Though the deadly entity was thought to be hidden for the whole movie, there is a theory suggesting that viewers do see the witch in The Blair Project after all. Back in 1999, The Blair Witch Project took the world by surprise with its intriguing marketing campaign which advertised the movie as showing the real footage of a group of young filmmakers who got lost in the woods in their search for the legendary Blair Witch. Thanks to this and more, The Blair Project revived the found footage technique in the horror genre, influencing movies like Cloverfield, REC, and Paranormal Activity.
✕ Remove Ads
The ending of The Blair Witch Project implies that Heather, Mike, and Josh died and the witch was responsible, but the witch is never actually shown on screen. While there are a number of supernatural threats in horror movies that never actually appear on screen, there is a clever theory that suggests the audience does see the witch and that this evil entity was really just hiding in plain sight.
Theory: Mary Brown Is The Real Blair Witch
The Supposed Blair Witch Survivor Could Be The Real Threat

When the main characters, Heather, Josh, and Mike, arrived in Burkittsville, they interviewed town residents for their documentary, and they all shared what they had been told about the Blair Witch and the horrible crimes they believed she had been responsible for. The group was told to visit a woman named Mary Brown (Patricia DeCou), who claimed to be the only person who survived an encounter with the Blair Witch.
✕ Remove Ads
Mary Brown told the group about the time she saw the witch when she was a kid, describing her as being covered head to toe in thick fur. Their conversation with Mary Brown was brief and easy to forget, but a Reddit user suggests that she might have actually been the Blair Witch.
Mary Brown was visibly mentally unstable, and back in the car, Heather mentioned that she made strange claims and even told them a Bible quote that they believed made no sense and had nothing to do with what they were doing. But Mary Brown might have actually warned the group through the Bible quote, which a Reddit user believes was Genesis 31:52, which none of the characters took seriously until they saw the piles of rock and began to feel a strange presence in the woods. The quote reads:
This pile of rocks and this one special rock both help us to remember our agreement. I will never go past these rocks to fight against you, and you must never go on my side of these rocks to fight against me.
✕ Remove Ads
Another Reddit user pointed out that, when the camera pans to show their surroundings at Mary Brown's home, the door to her trailer has sticks and twine like those the stick figures they find in the woods are made of, suggesting that it was Mary Brown, aka the Blair Witch, who made the stick figures. As for the piles of rocks, the witch was warning them about not respecting her limits, and once they kicked over the rocks and walked past them, she unleashed her full power and the horrors began for Heather, Mike, and Josh.
Would The Blair Witch Project’s Mary Brown Be A Supernatural Being?
Mike And Josh's Behavior Suggests A Supernatural Element
✕ Remove Ads
If Mary Brown is the Blair Witch, there’s the question of whether she’s a supernatural being or a human witch. The Blair Witch Project hints at Mike and Josh being possessed by the witch at different points throughout the movie, most notably when Mike reveals that he got rid of the map, which is why they ended up getting lost in the woods. It has also been theorized that the Blair Witch took the characters back in time, which is why they couldn’t find their way back to their car and why they weren’t found.
Mary Brown, then, could be a supernatural being posing as a human, and once Heather, Mike, and Josh crossed her limits in the woods, she unleashed her full power. However, it could also be that Mary Brown was a human witch who was so clever that she successfully messed with the characters’ heads through fear, telling them things that were supposedly nonsensical, leaving stick figures and rocks around them, and messing with their personal belongings as well.
✕ Remove Ads
Mary Brown Being The Blair Witch Makes The Movie's Story Creepier
The Witch Making Herself Known Is More Threatening
The Blair Witch Project is already scary even though the title witch is never shown, nor are any of the dangers around Heather, Mike, and Josh. The only hints the audience has that they are being followed are strange noises outside their tents at night, the stick figures, and piles of rocks. Once they enter the woods, they are the only people shown there, yet there’s clearly another presence around.
Mary Brown being the Blair Witch makes the movie creepier because the crew literally met the witch and even got her on video, but they made the big mistake of thinking Mary Brown was just a mentally unstable woman who lived alone –though on the other hand, this also means they succeeded in finding the witch and showing her in their documentary.
✕ Remove Ads
The Movie Is Scarier If You Don't See The Witch
The Unseen Villain Can Be More Effective
While the "Mary Brown is the true Blair Witch" theory is a clever one, the movie does not need the witch to be on screen to be effective, and it actually works better without that element. The fear of being unable to see the danger is one of the most effective tricks in horror and has been utilized endlessly by great movies in the genre. Perhaps the most famous and effective instance is the shark in Jaws, whose presence is felt every time the water is shown, even though it is only seen fully on camera in the final act.
✕ Remove Ads
The Blair Witch Project relies on the ability to tell an effectively scary story on a low budget and the unseen yet terrifying threat is the best method of accomplishing this. A big theme in the movie is the idea of the belief in the supernatural. These young people go out into the woods to discover the truth behind the legend, not willing to accept the tall tales as fact.
Likewise, with the found footage approach and the clever marketing campaign of the movie, audiences were also meant to accept The Blair Witch Project as a true story. Seeing the witch would have broken that reality, but keeping the threat unseen allows the movie to maintain the sense that it could all be real, while also presenting the characters and the audience with enough evidence that they cannot deny that there is something unexplained involved.

Your Rating
Rate Now 0/10
Leave a Review
Your comment has not been saved
19 5.8/10
The Blair Witch Project
R
Horror
Mystery
The Blair Witch Project is a 1999 horror film that follows three film students who venture into the Black Hills near Burkittsville, Maryland. As they document their search for the Blair Witch legend, strange and unsettling events unfold. Presented as found footage, the film is directed by Daniel Myrick and Eduardo Sánchez, and it pioneered the found footage genre in mainstream cinema.
- Director
- Eduardo Sánchez , Daniel Myrick
- Release Date
- July 30, 1999
- Cast
- Joshua Leonard , Michael C. Williams , Heather Donahue
- Runtime
- 81 minutes
✕ Remove Ads